Jennifer Smith, chair of the New York State Bar Association’s Law, Youth and Citizenship Committee, reflected on April 7 about the life and influence of Judith S. Kaye, who was the first woman to serve as chief judge of the New York Court of Appeals and remains its longest-serving leader. Smith shared personal memories and lessons learned from working closely with Judge Kaye during her career in law.
Judge Kaye is remembered not only for her legal achievements but also for her impact on those around her. Smith said that while Judge Kaye was recognized for her intellect and executive skills, it was often the smaller moments that left a lasting impression. “I will always be in awe of the mark Judge Kaye left on New York jurisprudence, and I know I am not alone,” Smith said.
Smith described how working with Judge Kaye helped her continue practicing law during a challenging period balancing family responsibilities. She recalled that Judge Kaye preferred perseverance over ambition, once saying she did not “lean in” so much as “hang in.” In a lighthearted moment reflecting this approach to professionalism, Judge Kaye would say: “I don’t give advice except, don’t wear a wrap dress.” This remark highlighted one of her core beliefs: there are no shortcuts or substitutes for preparation and care in professional life.
The article details how clothing held significance for Judge Kaye as a form of communication. Known for wearing red shoes under her judicial robes—a symbol she hoped would encourage more women judges—she collected red shoe memorabilia throughout her career. Her commitment extended beyond work attire; she made time for both family and professional obligations without minimizing either.
Judge Kaye’s work ethic was described by Smith as unwavering: “Her dedication to legal writing is legendary.” She balanced intense preparation with kindness toward colleagues at all levels, remembering names and unique facts about everyone at Skadden Arps where she worked after leaving the court.
The New York State Bar Association fosters cultural well-being through initiatives promoting equal access to justice according to its official website. The association operates administrative functions from its Bar Center in Albany according to its official website and includes members from all U.S. states and over 100 countries worldwide according to its official website. It supports legislative efforts upholding justice while advancing member success according to its official website.
Smith concluded by recalling ongoing inspiration drawn from Judge Kaye’s example: “Be prepared. Be kind… Work hard but enjoy the breaks if you can take them… Dress like you give a damn.” The story serves as both tribute and reminder of broader values promoted by leaders like Chief Judge Judith S. Kaye.
